| Platinum | House of Bread |
| Gold | Ogi's European Bakery and Deli |
| Silver | Bresnan Bread & Pastry |
| Bronze | The Donut Kitchen |
| Top Pick | Bradford Bakery |
| Top Pick | Cremcrittos Patisserie |
| Top Pick | Parlor Doughnuts McKinney |
| Top Pick | Princess Snickerdoodle |
| Top Pick | Sweet Art Bakery |